• Bio
    • Media Appearances
  • Kayak Fishing
    • Hank’s Kayak Fishing History
    • Kayak Fishing Posts
    • A Carolina Trail
    • Kayak Fishing for Bowfin
    • Field Reports
  • Bowfin
    • Bowfin Fishing
    • Bowfin Resources
  • Writings
    • Fishing Essays
    • Fishing Book Reviews
    • Product Reviews
    • Jackson Kayak Blog
    • Welcome to Bowfin Country: The Book
  • Sponsors

Welcome to Bowfin Country

Welcome to Bowfin Country

Tag Archives: Book of the Black Bass

The Erroneous Classic : Dr. James A. Henshall’s Book of the Black Bass

17 Friday Mar 2017

Posted by Henry Veggian in Book Reviews, Writings

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

19th century Fish Biology, 19th century Fishing Literature, B.A.S.S., Bass Fishing, Book of the Black Bass, Dr. James Henshall, fish biology, Largemouth Bass

James Henshall ‘s Book of the Black Bass was published in 1881. Today it is a considered a classic; for example, the edition I read was a reprint published by B.A.S.S. It is a strange book to qualify as a classic because it is littered with hearsay, the prose is often extravagant (but not always) and many of the scientific facts it alleges are simply wrong. Furthermore, Henshall was limited by tackle options (in those days, fly lines were made of silk and horse hair that had to be hung and dried after use, and bait casting reels –minnow casters, he calls them – were a new idea). How then is it a classic? Because Henshall was the first to argue at length for the merits of the Black Bass species as game fish, and to do so mustering all the available scientific knowledge  to make his case. What is most interesting is that he did so at a time when the Black Bass was not considered a sport fish (he uses the term “Black Bass” to describe the Largemouth, but implies the Smallmouth and other sub-species). In short, Henshall’s book is filled with mistakes, but if you read it Book of the Black Bass carefully you can hear the modern bass angler’s bluster and bounce; read it with an eye for his arguments against the American trout monopoly, and you will see why he was eventually persuasive, even prophetic.

Nonetheless, to the modern bass angler looking for fishing advice or modern scientific data (not to mention a more readable style of prose), the Book of the Black Bass will resemble a work of fiction written by the good Doctor Frankenstein. In the first place, the book is longer than Abe Lincoln’s beard, numbering 455 pages. Henshall divided it in three parts, each with its faults and merits, so I will review each section in turn.

Spine of the B.A.S.S. reprint of Book of the Black Bass

Continue reading →

Follow Hank on Youtube

https://youtu.be/4wrGRk5mnNs

Receive new post notice by email.

Join 1,898 other subscribers

RSS Welcome to Bowfin Country

  • Fish Psych 101: Reflections on a Hot Streak (part II)
  • Learning the Water: Kayak Tournament Fishing in Falls Lake
  • Jackson Kayak Blog Posts 2022
  • Jackson Kayak Blog Posts 2021
  • Jackson Kayak Blog Posts 2020
  • Fish Psych 101: Reflections on a Hot Streak (I)
  • The Extraordinary Complexity of a Fishing Life: A Review of Janet Messineo’s Casting into the Light (2019)
  • Kayak Fishing: Wading, Portaging and Fishing in Fast Water
  • Form and Void: A Review of the Wilderness Systems Kayak Krate
  • Kayak Fishing in Carolina Country Magazine

Twitter Feed

My Tweets

Flickr Photos

outdoor life april 2017HV Shearon harris Channel Catfish 6 (5)U lake 7.25 21.75 July 2020 (6)IMG_0175
More Photos

Relevant Web Sites

  • Hank's youtube Channel

Blog Stats

  • 15,638 hits

Archives

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Follow Following
    • Welcome to Bowfin Country
    • Join 36 other followers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • Welcome to Bowfin Country
    • Customize
    • Follow Following
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar
 

Loading Comments...